This is something that comes up often in both my classes and my private training and behaviour work and tackling it is vital for successful behaviour change – whether training your dog to come back when called or to not freak out when walking past another dog.

Do not let your dog rehearse the behaviour you don’t like.

It’s essential. There’s no getting round it. Every single time you allow your dog to do the very thing that you don’t want him to do he has just got that little bit better at it. He’s strengthened those neural pathways and made it more likely to happen again in the future.

Remember that conversation we had last week about changing the probability of behaviour? Well this is part of that equation. If we don’t manage the existing behaviour we will never weaken that well worn pathway your dog has created and we’ll also make it much much harder to teach an alternative.

Think of it like a path through the woods. A path is already well worn (that’s the existing behaviour) it’s been walked many times, in fact it’s so well worn that no grass is growing on it, it’s just bare earth.

We want to create a new path. It’s going to take a lot of walking to make it as obvious as the old path, especially if people keep walking down the old path too. And even if we did manage to make two well worn paths which one would people choose? – both are equally likely and we don’t really want that from our training.

Two paths in the woods, which to choose?

Which path to choose? They are both equally likely

What we need to do is block the old path to allow the grass and undergrowth to grow back, maybe even the odd tree. The gate preventing access allows the vegetation to grow, but more importantly stops people wandering down the once obvious path, making the newer path (that we’re going to signpost to make it easier) a better choice.

As time goes on the new path becomes more worn, we could even lose the signs but people would still take it, it’s a clear road. Eventually the old path will disappear from view and we could remove the blockade because the new path is so blinding obvious and easy to use. We’ve successfully changed peoples’ behaviour, they are consistently using the new path while the old path remains disused. (In behaviour terms it still exists, but that’s a topic for another day).

Overgrown path in the woods

We want overgrown paths for behaviours we don’t like

So how do we prevent our dog’s from practising stuff we don’t like? –  Management.

This is absolutely where every single one of my training plans for clients starts. If we can’t change the environment to make it far less likely that he will show the problem behaviour we are already losing. If your dog is already doing something you wish he wasn’t we have got to stack the deck, because what we want him to do isn’t going to magically happen, otherwise he’d already be doing it.

So what does this mean in reality?

If your dog is barking and lunging at other dogs out and about – you generally need to give him more space, walk him places you’ll see fewer dogs and where you’ll have more room to manoeuvre to give him the space he so desperately needs.

If your dog isn’t coming back when called because he’s more interested in running up to other dogs or chasing small furry things, use a harness and long line so he can’t practise taking off. Walk in places where there are fewer of those types of distractions.

If your dog is barking at people walking past the front of the house, use something to block his vision – that sticky window film is great. I’ve got it at home and not because of the dogs – I didn’t want net curtains! You can even get static stuff that lasts ages but is easy to peel off.

You get the idea….

None of these things alone is going to totally fix the problem, you’ve still got work to do if you really want to get to the bottom of it, but it’s the first step. I think the most important one. And for some behaviours it’s all you need to do to fix the problem.

For instance one of my German Shepherds used to launch himself at the front door when post came through the letterbox. The solution? – an outside post box and taping up the letter box so the postie couldn’t accidentally send post through the door. Problem solved, no training necessary, my dog wasn’t bothered about people coming up to the door, just the stuff suddenly coming through it.

I’m always going to tell you that we need to manage the existing behaviour first, but I’ll help you come up with a practical way to do that for you and your dog, because everyone is different.

If your dog is practising a behaviour you don’t like and you want some help in figuring out a way to change it, that’s what my private training and behaviour packages are for. Get in touch ( and we’ll come up with a plan – starting with management.